Contact Us

The Beatles are NOT a Boy Band! — So Who Is?

The Beatles
The Beatles, Facebook

If you’re a ’90s kid like myself, chances are, you spent your childhood getting your fill of so-called “boy bands.” They weren’t the first — oh, hey, NKOTB — or the last — apparently there’s something called a One Direction that’s all the rage right now? — but with groups like 98 Degrees, the Backstreet Boys, *NSYNC, O-Town and even the MTV-made, fake-but-not-really 2gether, the late ’90s were basically the heyday of boy bands.

Or were they? After all, has anyone actually determined what, exactly, constitutes a “boy band”?

Evidently, they haven’t. After Thought Catalog posted about “9 Songs That Redeem All Boy Bands,” Joe DiNardo and I couldn’t help but start debating…and then dragging a few Twitter followers into it, too.

What Do You Consider a "Boy Band"?

An office debate about what constitutes a boy band turned into a Twitter discussion debating the same. Many, many @replies and some yelling later, we’re still no closer to figuring out the answer — but it sure was entertaining!

Storified by Angela Stefano · Thu, Jul 05 2012 11:32:14

Do you consider The Beatles a "boy band"? What, exactly, constitutes a "boy band"? @joedinardo and I are debating.Angela Stefano
Gonna argue that "boy band" has evolved through the years, but Beatles/Monkees/etc. are deff. early forerunners.Angela Stefano
@Bflo_girl @amstefano988 The Beatles are absolutely NOT a boy band. Unless N’Sync released a Sargent Pepper’s I’m unaware ofJoe DiNardo
@amstefano988 They were a boyband at the start, but they kind of transcended that later in their career because their sound matured.Caitlin Tremblay
@amstefano988 @ctrembz @joedinardo it shouldn’t even be a debate? Girls passing out in airports? Catchy pop tunes? Boy band.Elizabeth Callahan
Rare Beatlemania Footage!nocovercharge
@joedinardo @bflo_girl @amstefano988 @ctrembz The Beatles were a rock band. And that is that.Stephanie
@Bflo_girl @amstefano988 @ctrembz BOY BANDS DON’T PLAY THEIR OWN INSTRUMENTS OR WRITE THEIR OWN SONGS. They sing and dance. /finJoe DiNardo
@buttrfly20sl @joedinardo @amstefano988 You’re going to tell me Hold Your Hand isn’t a pop song? She loves you….yeah yeah yeah.Elizabeth Callahan
The Beatles – I Want To Hold Your Handtooshortxdanao
@Bflo_girl @joedinardo @amstefano988 they can have pop music and still not be a boy band. It’s almost an insult to their musical talent.Stephanie
@Bflo_girl @buttrfly20sl @amstefano988 Just because a band has all dudes and sings pop music doesn’t make them a boy band!!!!Joe DiNardo
@joedinardo @buttrfly20sl @amstefano988 so what is a boy band?Elizabeth Callahan
@amstefano988 @joedinardo @bflo_girl Music type and the shrieking age demographic of the female fans.Caitlin Tremblay
@joedinardo @Bflo_girl @buttrfly20sl @amstefano988 I think the key difference is that the beatles wrote their own music, boy bands don’tAngela K
@akepps @joedinardo @Bflo_girl @buttrfly20sl But it’s bc they were manufactured, not that they didn’t have the talent (although some didn’t)Angela Stefano
@buttrfly20sl @joedinardo @amstefano988 JC and Justin wrote and produced many of the tracks on Celebrity.Elizabeth Callahan
N Sync – Girlfriendnsyncvevo
@buttrfly20sl @joedinardo @bflo_girl @amstefano988 I’m going to be nosy and butt in. Beatles, not a boy band. Heart throbs early on? Yes.bryan
@buttrfly20sl @joedinardo @amstefano988 the beatles: Moulded into a professional act by manager Brian EpsteinElizabeth Callahan
@amstefano988 @ctrembz @bflo_girl Boy Bands are created as products. The Beatles were a band that was cleaned up to be more appealing. FACTSJoe DiNardo
@joedinardo @ctrembz @bflo_girl There are plenty of groups that had a member or two brought in, not just formed organically.Angela Stefano
@amstefano988 @ctrembz @bflo_girl Not by "marketing"\Joe DiNardo
@joedinardo @ctrembz @bflo_girl How is an agent/manager advertising for members any different than the band doing so?Angela Stefano
@amstefano988 @ctrembz @bflo_girl Talent vs. ProductJoe DiNardo
@joedinardo @ctrembz @bflo_girl Both looking for a specific outcome that’s somehow product-related.Angela Stefano
Now @joedinardo is trying to classify @springsteen and the Rolling Stones as boy bands.Angela Stefano
Rolling Stones Gimme Shelter 1970nickyr2
@amstefano988 by your and @ctrembz ‘s definition they are.Joe DiNardo
@joedinardo @ctrembz Rolling Stones were rock, not pop. Would you call The Ramones or Sex Pistols a boy band? (No.)Angela Stefano
@amstefano988 @joedinardo @springsteen Springsteen no, Stones yeah. Dirty boy band, but still kind of a boy band.Elizabeth Callahan
@Bflo_girl @joedinardo @ctrembz That’s why I don’t think that’s logical reasoning. It’s something other than created v. organic formation.Angela Stefano
@amstefano988 @joedinardo there’s no right answer or right way to classify any one band which is why such debates are so interesting.Caitlin Tremblay
And while we’re on the topic — How, then, do we define a "girl group"?Angela Stefano
@amstefano988 bands consisting of 100% females. Destiny’s Child, the Donnas….bryan
The Donnas – Take It Off (Video) Album Version audioatlanticvideos
@alifeinwords So with girl groups, the musical talent doesn’t matter? They’re all just in that category?Angela Stefano
@amstefano988 I guess. I don’t mean "girl group" as a knock or as sexist. Hell, most girl groups market themselves as so.bryan
I call an end to this debate. Need to cull this into a post, and my head is spinning! @joedinardo @Bflo_girl @ctrembz @alifeinwordsAngela Stefano
@amstefano988 @joedinardo @ctrembz @alifeinwords ha! And we didn’t even touch "girl groups/bands" #SpiceGirlsForLifeElizabeth Callahan
@Bflo_girl @amstefano988 and Destiny’s Child #bootylicious and Salt N Pepa #yoyoyoyobabypopsyeahyoucomeheregivemeakissCaitlin Tremblay
@ctrembz @amstefano988 only if we can also tackle En Vouge #YouHaveTheRightToLoseControlElizabeth Callahan

A flurry of @replies and some yelling later, we’re not any closer to figuring out the answer to this question. So, what do you think: What makes a “boy band” a boy band?

More From Jack FM

Best of the Web

Leave a Comment

It appears that you already have an account created within our VIP network of sites on . To keep your points and personal information safe, we need to verify that it's really you. To activate your account, please confirm your password. When you have confirmed your password, you will be able to log in through Facebook on both sites.

Forgot your password?

*Please note that your points, prizes and activities will not be shared between programs within our VIP network.

It appears that you already have an account on this site associated with . To connect your existing account with your Facebook account, just click on the account activation button below. You will maintain your existing profile and VIP program points. After you do this, you will be able to always log in to http://929jackfm.com using your Facebook account.

*Please note that your points, prizes and activities will not be shared between programs within our VIP network.

Please fill out the information below to help us provide you a better experience.

Register on 92.9 Jack FM quickly by logging in with your Facebook account. It's just as secure, and no password to remember!

Not a Member? Sign Up Here

Register on 92.9 Jack FM quickly by logging in with your Facebook account. It's just as secure, and no password to remember!