Before we get to Fall around Western New York, go grab a peanut butter and jelly milkshake at Taffy's in Orchard Park or hit up Antoinette's in Depew for one of their banana shakes! Here's the best of the best that are in your area!

  • 1

    Taffy's Hot Dog Stand

    3261 Orchard Park Rd, Orchard Park
  • 2

    Hannah's Frosty Treats

    140 Taunton Pl, Buffalo, NY
  • 3

    Antoinette Sweets

    5981 Transit Rd, Depew
  • 4

    Frosty's

    5500 Broadway, Lancaster / 2424 George Urban Blvd, Depew
  • 5

    The Pink Cow

    13119 Broadway, Alden
  • 6

    Lake Effect Diner

    3165 Main St, Buffalo
  • 7

    99 Fast Food Restaurant

    3396 Bailey Ave, Buffalo
  • 8

    Ted's

    All of them for cryin' out loud!
  • 9

    King Condrell's

    2805 Delaware Ave
  • 10

    Sweet Jenny's

    5732 Main St Williamsville